Equipment and vehicle finance
Chattel mortgage vs finance lease: which suits your business?
Quick answer
With a chattel mortgage, your business owns the vehicle or equipment from day one and the lender takes security over it. With a finance lease, the lender owns the asset and leases it to you, and you can usually buy it for a set residual at the end. An operating lease or rental suits assets you want to hand back or upgrade. The right choice depends mostly on whether you want to own the asset, how you account for GST, and how long you'll use it.
How a chattel mortgage works
A chattel mortgage is a business loan to buy a vehicle or piece of equipment. Your business owns the asset from the start, and the lender registers a security interest over it until the loan is repaid.
- Repayments are usually fixed for the term, often between one and seven years.
- You can add a balloon payment at the end to lower the regular repayments.
- If you're registered for GST, you may be able to claim the GST in the purchase price in your next BAS.
- The interest and the asset's depreciation may be tax deductible, in proportion to business use.
How a finance lease works
With a finance lease, the lender buys the asset and leases it to your business for a fixed term. You make regular lease payments, and at the end you can usually pay an agreed residual amount to take ownership, refinance the residual, or hand the asset back.
- The lender owns the asset during the lease.
- GST is charged on each lease payment rather than on the purchase price, and GST-registered businesses can generally claim it back over the term.
- Lease payments may be tax deductible in proportion to business use.
How an operating lease or rental works
An operating lease, sometimes called a rental agreement, lets your business use an asset for a set period without any residual to pay at the end. You return or upgrade the asset when the term ends. It suits technology and other equipment that goes out of date quickly, or assets you only need for a defined project.
Side-by-side comparison
| Chattel mortgage | Finance lease | Operating lease | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who owns the asset | Your business, from day one | The lender, until you pay the residual | The lender |
| GST | On the purchase price, may be claimable upfront | On each lease payment | On each rental payment |
| Possible tax deductions | Interest and depreciation | Lease payments | Rental payments |
| End of term | Optional balloon payment | Residual to buy, refinance or return | Return or upgrade |
| Often suits | Vehicles and equipment you'll keep | Businesses wanting even GST over the term | Technology and short-term needs |
Tax treatment depends on your business structure, how you account for GST and the percentage of business use. Check with your accountant before choosing.
What about novated leases?
A novated lease is a three-way agreement between an employee, their employer and a lender, with repayments taken from the employee's salary. It's for employees rather than businesses buying assets in their own name, so it's a different decision from the options above.
How to decide
- You want to own it and keep it for years: a chattel mortgage is the most common choice for vehicles and long-life equipment.
- You'd rather spread GST and keep the asset off your balance sheet until the end: look at a finance lease, and ask your accountant how it affects your accounts.
- You want to upgrade regularly: consider an operating lease or rental.
A broker who arranges these every week can show you the repayments for each structure on the same asset, so you can compare them properly.
Common questions
Is a chattel mortgage cheaper than a finance lease?
Not necessarily. The rate depends on the lender, the asset and your business. Compare the total cost, including any balloon or residual, and the tax and GST effect, rather than the rate alone.
Can I pay out a chattel mortgage early?
Usually yes, but many lenders charge an early payout fee or ask for the remaining interest. Check the contract before you sign.
Can I use a chattel mortgage for a used vehicle or equipment?
Yes. Chattel mortgages are available for new and used assets from dealers and private sellers. Lenders set limits on the asset's age at the end of the term.
This guide is general information only. It doesn't consider your circumstances and isn't financial, tax or credit advice. Talk to your accountant about tax, and to a licensed broker or lender about your options.